Here’s a summary of the discussion about Catherine’s cancer video and the mixed reactions it has received:

Initial Reaction: The speaker had a positive first impression of Catherine’s video, finding it heartfelt and impactful, but noted that royal commentators, particularly those from the Royal Rota, expressed criticism.
Critics’ Perspective: Commentators like Richard Eden from The Daily Mail pointed out that the absence of King Charles and Queen Camilla in the video was suspicious and criticized the display of affection between Catherine and William as “manipulative,” comparing it unfavorably to Princess Diana’s more traditional approach.
Changing Royal Image: The speaker argues that the royal family is evolving in response to changing times and the absence of Queen Elizabeth II. With her passing, a new generation of royals is attempting to modernize their image and approach.

Royal Media Control: The discussion highlights how social media has allowed royals to communicate directly with the public, reducing their reliance on traditional media outlets. This shift has led to tensions with the Royal Rota, who may feel sidelined.
Expectations of Vulnerability: Critics suggested that Catherine should showcase more vulnerable moments, like receiving treatment for cancer, but the speaker disagrees, asserting that such personal experiences should not be exploited for public consumption.
Distrust in Media: The speaker emphasizes a growing distrust between the royal family and the media, citing negative coverage during recent royal tours and the treatment of Catherine’s cancer diagnosis as reasons for the royals to take more control over their narrative.
Conclusion: The speaker encourages the royal family to maintain their independence in media interactions, advocating for a balance where they control their narrative while still engaging with traditional outlets to avoid the pitfalls of letting the media dictate their story.

This situation reflects broader themes of how modern royalty navigates public relations and the evolving expectations of royal family members in a changing media landscape.